The Best of Put‑In‑Bay

True, fantastic experience. A great staff and all of them were very friendly. Awesome rooms and room service. Fun pool and hot tub area. The outside swim up bar had exceptional food. Met the owner and his son. Would definitely stay at this resort every time we go to Put-In-Bay.

Awesome spot. Me and my 4 friends stayed in a luxury suite and it fit us just fine. Short walk to the pool bar and less then 10 minute walks to most everything else on the island. So it's a great location. The 24 hour desk comes in handy. We had a mix up with how many days we needed to stay. And they fixed it so fast. Katlyn and Steve should get a bonus for how well they're treating their customers. If you're coming to Put-in-Bay and you want a good location for a good price. The resort and conference center is a great spot.

Our visit to Put-In-Bay Resort exceeded expectations! The rooms and common areas were extremely clean and well-kept, which immediately made us feel comfortable and relaxed. The staff was amazing — so friendly, welcoming, and always ready to help. Whether it was answering questions, offering local tips, or helping with small requests, they were consistently kind and professional. What really impressed us was how accommodating they were throughout our stay. They made sure everything ran smoothly and that we had everything we needed to enjoy our trip. This resort strikes the perfect balance between fun and relaxation. We’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend it to anyone planning a trip to Put-In-Bay!

We had such a fantastic experience at Bay Lodging Resort! The entire property was spotless — from the lobby to the rooms, everything was clean and well-maintained. The staff truly went above and beyond; everyone we encountered was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and helpful. What really stood out was how accommodating they were. Whether it was a request for extra towels or help with recommendations around town, they made sure we felt comfortable and taken care of every step of the way. If you’re looking for a place that’s clean, comfortable, and staffed by people who genuinely care about your stay, Bay Lodging is it. Highly recommend — we’ll definitely be back!

Absolutely Fantastic Stay! From the moment we arrived, the service was top-notch. Maddy at the front desk was incredibly welcoming and helpful, as she made check-in a breeze and set the tone for a great stay. The room was absolutely amazing with clean, spacious, and beautifully appointed with everything we needed. Colin at the bar was amazing! Not only were the drinks perfect, but his energy and friendliness made every visit to the bar a highlight of our trip. Amber was incredibly helpful, answering all our questions with patience and a smile. Whether we needed directions, recommendations, or just a quick chat, she was always there with the right answer. This hotel exceeded all our expectations thanks to the incredible staff. We’ll definitely be back!

My husband and I were pleasantly surprised at what a great stay we had. Heard that the owners purchased the property not long ago. They obviously did their homework because our suite was very clean and they supplied the necessities as if it were a five star hotel. The owners and staff were friendly and helpful. I spoke to others who were staying there and their experience was as pleasant as ours! The accessibility to the business district and harbor was a minute away. Can't beat that! We are definitely coming back for another stay! Thanks to the owners and staff for a wonderful experience at Bay Lodging Resort!